The finish on the black set looked nice once installed, and they feel better than the super-cheap generic tuners you usually find in this price range. Compared with basic non-locking Musiclily sets, these at least feel like a meaningful step up in usability. I put these on an Epiphone-style 3x3 headstock, and for the money, I think they’re a pretty solid upgrade. They’re still budget hardware, not premium Gotoh/Grover-level tuners. They work well, but the turning feel on mine wasn’t perfectly identical across all six keys not bad, just not ultra-smooth boutique quality. Also, double-check your screw hole layout and peg hole size before buying, because fitment matters way more than the listing makes it sound.