Nice vintage looking string trees that would make very acceptable replacements on a Fender guitar, or as initial installs on your Partscaster build. Finish is smooth, and no rough edges are noted.I can't give it 5 stars; because the design limits their applicability. You'll see lots of string trees, here and elsewhere, that have a shorter stand-off shaft. These include two sets of mounting screws of different lengths and an adapter to increase the shaft length. This lets them be used on more instruments and different configurations. This is not one of those.So make sure the height is what you need to get your desired tension before ordering!