Had a broken knob on my Les Paul and decided to replace all four with these. The amber knobs do in fact look like the picture, but unfortunately, do not match the originals on my guitar. It's possible I should've ordered gold, but the gold in their picture looks even less like what I have, so will probably just settle with these.As for the knobs themselves, pretty cheap all around. You can see the comparison between these and the originals that came with my guitar. That said, they were only $6 so I can't really expect much. If these are important factors for you, I'd just pay the extra money and get the official knobs. Otherwise, these will probably get the job done.